The Christ of the Indian Road - E. Stanley Jones
I feel like this man and I would have been close friends. I wish I had known E. Stanley Jones. He was obsessed with the Kingdom, but his first book was engagement with India. That’s exactly what happened to me. I knew all the stuff intellectually, but it wasn’t until I began to experience Vietnam that everything began to change. I wonder if you can truly be “missional” without getting outside your own culture. I heard a line in a movie, “anthropologists say you truly can’t understand your culture until you live in another culture.”I’m re-reading The Christ of the Indian Road. This guy is so current, and this book was written in 1925! “Christian missions have come to a crisis in India. A new and challenging situation confronts us. If we are to meet it, we must boldly follow the Christ into what are, to us, untried paths. In order to understand these modern movements one must know the past, and must keep constantly in mind the foundations that have been laid for this new day by the patient toil and sacrificial living of generations. . . “
I wonder what the world would have looked like if his philosophy of missions had caught on quicker. How did WWII disrupt and impact this way of thinking? Was Jones a prophet for us from the past whose works now uncovered give us clues? Can the future be found from the past, buried as pearls in fields long grown over and forgotten?
Jones in his preface to the sixth edition has faced criticism because he didn’t talk about the caste system, the poverty, Hinduism, etc. He says he leaves this out for 3 reasons:
First, “India is aggrieved, and I think rightly so, that Christian missionaries in order to arouse the West to missionary activity have too often emphasized the dark side of the picture. What they have said has been true, but the picture has not been a true one. This overemphasis on one side has often created either pity or contempt . . . a superiority complex has resulted. I do not believe a superiority complex is the proper spring for missionary activity. Eastern travelers in America, picking and choosing their facts, can make out a very dark picture of our civilization-the slums, lynchings, divorce statistics, crime statistics unparalleled in other cities of the world” (and this was 1925!).
Second, “Indians themselves are now alive to these evils and are combating them. The fact is that racial lines are so drawn so that India will probably deal more drastically with her evils if she does it from within than if we as foreigners were always insisting upon it” (Where are you E. Stanley--would to God we could understand in our current global situation.)
Third, “I have tried to lay the foundations for Christian missions deeper than upon particular evils found in a particular race. . . I do not make a special drive . . . because you are the neediest people of our race, but because you are a member of our race. I am convinced that the only kind of a world worth having is a world patterned after the mind and spirit of Jesus. . . We are all in the same deep need. Christ, I believe, can supply that need.”
One final note. After Jones returned from his first trip to India someone said, of him, “He has probably done some good to India, but India has certainly done a great deal for him.”
YES I DO mespel some words! But as a “blogger” I write more from passion than grammar. My assistant tries to help me!!!! When you read things like that PBP with me!



Comments
Sep 29, 2007 at 05:19 AM
Bob,
Wonderful post. I haven't read this book but it is on my shortlist.
Why are we as missional folks so afraid to let the Holy Spirit do his work in a culture? Why do we feel like we have to make sure transformation happens in a way that we are comfortable with or that we can control? I think that our desire to avoid syncretism often squelches the work of the Holy Spirit, and this is sad.
I know I don't understand this fully, but my experience in more than 20 different cultures is showing me that we must live out the gospel of the Kingdom and let the Holy Spirit do his work of transformation in the lives of our disciples.
Thanks again for keeping these things out front for us.
Until ALL Have Heard,
jeg
-----
Sep 29, 2007 at 11:39 AM
I agree with you. BUT, you make my case - you began to understand that as a result of engaging other cultures - not reading a book - developing a "missional" theology - or hearing an inspiring speaker.
Sep 30, 2007 at 06:35 AM
Bob,
True, but, a very large percentage of the people I meet who live and work in different cultures still don't seem to even be close to understanding this. There seems to still be a strong desire to control the outcome of what the church in a different culture will look like (meaning it must look like it does here in the West). I think this may be one of the major weaknesses in the missionary force we are sending out. If this is truly the case, how do we change it? Better pre-field training? Perhaps, we can learn to plant churches in the many sub-cultures of US life in a way that allows the Holy Spirit to control the outcome and looks of the new church? I don't know, but I do think it is a major issue in missions these days.
Thanks,
jeg
Jun 12, 2008 at 08:17 AM
Hello stupid pendosegi.b
Jun 12, 2008 at 08:18 AM
You have built a good websitea
Leave a Reply