GlocalNet

Connecting for Glocal Transformation

Descending into Chaos in Gaza

image
image

There are over 1200 tunnels from Gaza to the Egyptian side.  When Egypt opens the border people can flow in and out, but when they don’t there is only one way to get in fuel, food, and other supplies just for survival - the tunnels.  These are NOT tourist sites for sure, and there is a lot of danger involved in them.  I went down on a small platform 30 meters or more and began to walk through the tunnel.  At some point someone’s cell phone buzzed with a text message saying “You are now in Egypt, rates and services are . . . . ”  It was small and narrow and I had to bend over most of the way just to walk.  Parts of the walls were shored up with wood, and other parts weren’t.  It’s a source of income for many young men who have no other way to make a living.  When we came out, just a few yards up the road, there was a lot of emergency equipment.  A group of 6 young men were hauling back gasoline, and something sparked and they were burned and buried in a tunnel.  A guy in broken English standing beside said “Pray for that man” - it was a man on his knees catching his breath at the entrance of the tunnel where the guys were buried.  I asked why, he said, “He’s got to go in and get them - he’s a dead man.”  I heard the next day that 7 lives were lost - was it a miscount on the 6 the night before or did that guy not make it?  I’m not sure. 

There were some things that amazed me in Gaza that I didn’t expect - I’ve been in war zones before - this one was different.  I’ve been told there is a news black out from the West on Gaza due to inaccessibility and I should write what I saw - so here goes:

1.  They were open to dialogue and working with an evangelical Christian like me.  I was there to see about helping find some eye doctors.  I met with a key group of leaders and asked them, “How many of you have ever heard of an evangelical Christian?” They all raised their hands.  “How many of you have ever met one?”  Not a single one raised their hand.  I told them, “Contrary to what you may have heard from others, we are not all terrorist!”  They roared laughing. 

2.  Not everyone is a member of Hamas - I met key government leaders that worked in the government but weren’t a member of the party.  Hamas won the elections and if you work with the government it’s the party that won, but not everyone is in that party, just like the U.S.

3.  These are some of the most educated people on the face of the earth to be experiencing what they are.  In Hamas alone, there are 500 PhD’s and in Gaza a few thousand - most western educated.  When you talk to them, they are intelligent, poised, conversant, thoughtful in their responses, and not dummies.  I met MD’s, film producers, businessmen, as well as everyday hard working people - and they were just that - people.  People that under other circumstances you’d be friends with, go out and hang out with and enjoy spending time with. 

4.  They are incredibly calm.  The picture I had in my mind was they were desperate without thinking of their situation just trying to survive.  It was a wrong picture.  I visited with one man whose son was lost in war a few months ago - he was not bitter or full of hate.  He told me, “I want my sons and daughters to grow up free in their homeland just like you want your son and daughter to be free in your Texas.  If you had people coming and trying to drive you out of your homes and houses for centuries I doubt you would sit by and do nothing.” 

5.  They don’t like the way they are perceived and don’t want to be isolated.  They don’t consider themselves terrorist and feel like they’ve all been put in that box.  They asked me how they could change that.  I told them to stop the rockets, along with a few other things . . . . I asked them and one person in particular who is a leader, “Why the suicide bombers?”  His response to me was, “You have drones in Afghanistan that kill innocent people - we are fighting for our freedom and sadly civilian casualties happen.”  He gave me many other examples.  We sat in his small orchard at his house and talked - he didn’t yell or protest.  He was very engaging to talk with.  He had also lost sons in the conflict. 

6.  They were told they should become a part of the political process from the Americans before the elections a couple of years back, and if they would, they could get their voice out in a more civil way - so they did.  They don’t understand why America didn’t back them if they were moving into the civil political process.  A week later I was with some other diplomats from around the world discussing the whole issue and one told me, “We’re not saying we agree with Hamas, but when there was no good solution we made it possible.” 

7.  Hamas has brought order to the streets along with security, and services to the people.  Before they won the elections it was like the Wild West - people with warring factions and everyone with their guns on the street.  Now, you don’t see that except for soldiers posted throughout the city.  They have brought humanitarian help to their people, and they have brought order.

8.  Dialogue and action needs to be taking place - maybe it is and I just don’t know about it - but when you pen 1.5 million people up in a cage on top of one another you can’t expect everyone to act “reasonably” or “sanely” from “unreasonable” or “insane” conditions.  Nothing good can or will come from the current status that Gaza finds itself in - nothing good for them and nothing good for the Israeli’s.  As someone who admires and loves both Jews and Palestinians I’m grateful Obama has changed the rhetoric early in his administration.  Personally and selfishly, beyond my Christian responsibility of care, love, and compassion - I want it fixed.  I don’t want my son or daughter, or the children of my church to have to go fight in an unreasonable and unstoppable war (of course maybe they all are).  If you are going to address poverty - you go to Africa.  If you are going to deal with the key issues of peace and alleviate war - more than anywhere else - you have to address the crisis in Israel.  60 years of guns and violence has not solved it and will not.  It’s time for a different approach. 

 

Comments

  • John Lanferman says:
    Aug 11, 2009 at 08:38 AM
    Bob, this is so helpful. Thank you for presenting an excellent picture of the issues facing Palestinians and Israelis and avoiding the unhelpful theological diatribe that most often clouds the real issues for christians in western culture.
  • Tim Wright says:
    Aug 11, 2009 at 06:13 PM
    Hi,

    Encouraging to hear some good news. Look at the west bank, they don't fire rockets at Israel and have a healthy economy. The fight is between Israel and Iran and the folks in Gaza are in a proxy battle. The NY Times did an excellent series on this idea. People stop fighting when THEY get tired of fighting, not the people watching them get tired of watching them fighting.

    Tim
  • Darrel Jorgensen says:
    Aug 11, 2009 at 06:44 PM
    So who is firing rockets into Israel? The people you met may have said they were not Hamas but what makes you think they were telling the truth? It seems the civilian population must take some responsibility because they hide and protect those that fire the rockets. You would probably enjoy reading "Understanding the Arab-Israeli Conflict" by Michael Rydelnik
  • roby says:
    Aug 11, 2009 at 07:15 PM
    Bob, did you ask them if they are willing to accept the existence of Israel in the same piece of land?

    Roby
  • Vicky Porterfield says:
    Aug 12, 2009 at 12:11 AM
    Did you see any followers of Jesus in Gaza? I know that the Christian book store was destroyed and its owner killed a couple of years ago. I am praying for the witness of light and life to be revealed there. Also for courageous leaders for both the Paliestinians and Israelis. Both sides need Jesus!

    Thanks for sharing your story, Bob since you were able to see what many of us cannot.
  • Bob Roberts Jr. says:
    Aug 12, 2009 at 04:16 AM
    Trust me, there is enough blame on both sides go all the way around. Yes, there were people willing to go a two-state solution. Yes, I saw some Jesus followers. I've yet to be anywhere in the world they are not present.
  • Mike Barnett says:
    Aug 12, 2009 at 05:37 AM
    Good report Bob! Thanks for sharing some of the realities of Palestine. It always amazed me how we Americans can visit Israel and never encounter Palestinians! We have such a skewed view of that part of the world. It was also complicated when Jesus visited. Thanks Bob for a reality check--a below ground level view. We look forward to seeing how God uses you and your group in Palestine.
  • Safi Kaskas says:
    Aug 12, 2009 at 05:55 AM
    Bob, You are a courageous man. You report what you see. Many people go to the Middle East see the truth and are afraid to report it. When we talk about Israel right to exist, do we consider other people right to exist in their ancestral land as well? Did Jesus teach us to choose which enemy to love and which enemy to hate? Please, it is time to love both Palestinians and to show them that we accept them as God’s children. When we see them as agents to an Iranian proxy war with Israel we intentionally demonize them. God loves each one of us and we need to relate this love to all, one at a time. We love you Bob.
  • Andrew Schil says:
    Aug 12, 2009 at 09:57 AM
    Thanks Bob!! Your story is indeed powerful. I agree with Safi completely. We have to walk in a another man's shoes to really see where they are coming from, see what they have experienced and ultimately to know them. It is pretty hard to even take the first steps towards loving our enemies until we are willing to share in their suffering, even if separated by a vast ocean. This is the example of Jesus! This conflict isn't about choosing sides or picking a winner. It is about seeing Israelis and Palestinians, whether Muslim, Christian or Jew reconciled to each other and bound by the love of their creator.
  • Judy says:
    Aug 14, 2009 at 09:38 AM
    Thanks Bob.

    As an American woman who is married to a Gazan, I appreciate the fact that you went to Gaza, met with real people, and have reported the truth.

    I would encourage all of your readers to communicate with their elected representatives that we need a sane and balanced policy in the Middle East that recognizes the needs, rights and humanity of all parties.

    Our reps fear a powerful lobby and negative consequences. It's so easy to buy into the prevalent notion that Palestinians are Israel's Al-Qaeda. Those of us who know that is nonsense must speak out!

    Bottom line: this situation goes on because of our silence. If you care, speak out!

    PS... as to the reader who mentioned the economic situation in the West Bank... while the WB might live with less oppression, make no mistake: West Bank Palestinians live under a violent military occupation. Living with slight less Israeli tyranny should not be anyone's goal!
  • Dr Swee Ang says:
    Aug 14, 2009 at 12:47 PM
    Dear Bob,

    Thank you for sharing your experience in such a truthful way. I worked in Gaza as a doctor between 1988 and 1989. It was in a hospital run by the Episcopal Church. The hospital is called Al-Ahli Arab Hospital, and has been a Christian witness for more than a century. During that time, I worshipped weekly in the hospital Chapel with the hospital staff.

    I revisited the hospital in January 2009. after the recent Christmas war. The Palestinian Christian director Dr Sohaila Tarazi and the hospital Medical director showed me the Chapel which was destroyed by a laser guided bomb from an F16. We also discussed the wounded treated by the hospital during that time.

    There are many things I want to tell you about Gaza, but time and space will not allow me to at this point.

    However, when I think of our Christian brothers and sisters in Israel, Gaza and West Bank, I just feel their hurt. Not only the physical hurt of living under siege, occupation and war, but also that they sometimes feel that they are the neglected and abandoned part of the body of Christ. Please ask your congregation to pray for all the Christians of the Holy Land, and also for us so that we understand that we are all in Christ together. When they hurt, we hurt. When they rejoice, we rejoice. When they are strengthened, we are strengthened. Thus we can bear each other's burdens as the Lord has borne ours.

    In the Lord

    Dr Swee, 14 August 2009
  • Safi Kaskas says:
    Aug 14, 2009 at 03:32 PM
    I agree with Dr. Swee in his description to the pain and suffering of our Christian’s brothers and sisters in Palestine. I too feel their hurt. In fact for a long time, Israel did not want the world to realize that a large portion of the Palestinians are Christians.
    However, I wonder why we are asked to pray for our Christian brothers and sisters and not for all the oppressed Palestinians especially that Dr. Swee knows very well that the Israeli bullets do not differentiate between one Palestinian and another.
    Jesus wants us to love our neighbors and he ordered us to love our enemies. That includes all. His love was not directed toward some at the expense of others. At least, this is what this Muslim learned that followers of Jesus should do. Please join me in praying for all parties of this conflict, both the Palestinians and the Israelis and especially the American government that can positively contribute to a solution.
  • Dr Swee Ang says:
    Aug 15, 2009 at 05:29 AM
    I agree with Safi that we are all children of God independent of whether Christians, Muslims or Jews. I learnt that when I first worked in the Palestinian refugee camps of Lebanon in 1982. It is with pain that I ask Christians to acknowledge the suffering of Christians in the Holy Land. I dare not ask them to include the non-Christians in their prayer. Maybe I should have more faith than that Each year, millions of American and European Christians do pilgrimage to Israel, but they do not even acknowledge that Arab Christians exist, nevermind Muslims. That is my starting point.

    What I really mean to say is - if we as Christians do not care about Muslims then at least start by praying for the Christian family. If we cannot love our neighbours as commanded by Christ, then just start by loving our own family. My first Christmas in Gaza was in 1988, when Gaza was under curfew. My wounded patients - nearly all of them Muslims did not expect any solidarity from the West, but the hospital Christian staff did not even get one well wish from their Christian brothers and sisters from abroad.

    Since then the West Bank and Gaza have spent more Christmases under curfew. Christmas 2008 was celebrated in Gaza by months of siege and starvationas the run up, followed by bombs and shells - while churches in the West preached peace over the dead bodies of Palestinian children. My own church in London had to acknowledge the disaster in Gaza when I bought my plane ticket to go out there. A member of the Church was going out to Gaza against the advice of the British government.

    Contrast Beirut 2007 - After midnight mass in Bezbollah controlled areas - the worshippers come out of mass to find Hezbollah security men handing out chocolates to them. Hezbollah handing out chocolates to Arab Christians less than 2 years after their families and villages were destroyed by the 2006 invasion supported by Christian UK and USA.

    Safi - it is only when my Christian brothers and sisters begin to have the love of Jesus in their heart - and I pray for that many times a day, that they can love each other and their extended family. Then we can see that we are all part of God's family - that in Christ there is no slave or free, male or female, Jew or non-Jew, national or non-national, Jew Muslim or Christian - but we are all one in His family.
  • Tim Wright says:
    Aug 15, 2009 at 07:02 AM
    Hi,

    We should all we can love all people and Palestinians do not need their own country for them to respond to the love of Jesus, Couldn't have said it better.

    Tim
  • Judy Walker says:
    Aug 15, 2009 at 07:24 AM
    Dr. Swee is correct in noting that Palestinian Christians are invisible to many Christiains in the West, especially American evangelicals.

    I have always found this very curious. Can anyone shed light on this?
  • Safi Kaskas says:
    Aug 15, 2009 at 08:48 AM
    Dear Dr. Swee,

    Your reply brought tears to my eyes and then I started weeping when I felt the depth of your wound.

    I just came back to Jeddah from a month and a half visit to the States. Let me share some good news with you. While all is possible with the Lord, we have to understand that His timing is what matters not ours.

    For the first time after forty years of meeting and speaking to various American groups about the suffering of the Palestinians, this year I was invited to a meeting with American church leaders that wanted to know what is it that they can do to help the Palestinians within the occupied territories.

    Next March three thousand American church leaders are meeting in Bethlehem under the banner of Jesus to see firsthand the suffering of the Palestinians and to do what they can to help. I must say that the tide seems to be turning and this will be in the best interest of a possible future peace between the Israelis and the Palestinians.

    We trust in Him and we know that at the end His will, will be done.
  • Dr swee ang says:
    Aug 17, 2009 at 12:33 PM
    Thank you so much Safi for sharing the good news.

    Also thank you Bob for visiting Gaza and going out to heal the wounds, and for giving them a voice. We would continue in Faith, Hope and Love, and never despair.
  • Nabeel T. Jabbour says:
    Aug 17, 2009 at 04:00 PM
    Thank you to all of you who shared. I am proud to be a friend of Dr. Swee Ang. I am an adjunct professor at three evangelical seminaries in the States and at two seminaries in Canada. I teach two intensive courses: "Islam and Current Events", and "Radical Islam and A Christian Response."

    There is a great deal of diversity within the 1.4 Muslims around the world. Muslims belong to different citizenships,different races and they speak different langauges. Consciously or unconsciously they all agree mainly on four things.
    1. God is one.
    2. Muhammad is His prophet.
    3. The Qur'an is the holy Book.
    4. Palestinians experienced injustice and the West turned a deaf ear to their grievences.

    In Islam there is no separation between religion and state. Islam is a religion and a state. The silent majority of the 1.4 billion Muslims, are swayed either towards fanaticims and hatred or towards open minidedness and moderation. This is mainly dependent on how the West addresses the Israel/Palestine issue. The Gospel is at stake.

    Please read my book "The Crescent Through The Eyes of The Cross" published by Navpress.

Leave a Reply

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the word you see in the image below:


Blog Categories

Search Glocalnet

Support

Partners

Northwood Church Vision 360

Glocalnet Books